The
following contains questions and answers regarding NCAA football,
including bowl games, information on the BCS, the difference between
the Football Bowl Subdivision and Football Championship Subdivision,
and other helpful information.
1. Why is there no playoff/traditional championship structure in Division I-A football?
The
arrangement that determines a national champion in Division I-A
football -- the Bowl Championship Series -- is administered by the 11
Division I-A Conferences and the University of Notre Dame. The first
year of the BCS was 1998.
The BCS consists of five bowl games: the BCS National Championship
Game plus four other bowl games (Rose Bowl, Fiesta Bowl, Orange Bowl,
Sugar Bowl). The No. 1 and No. 2 teams in the final BCS standings meet
in the National Championship Game. This season, the championship game
is scheduled for January 8, 2007, in Glendale, Arizona.
Click here for the official BCS website:
http://www.bcsfootball.org/bcsfootball/
There are a total of 32 bowl games. Click here for a complete list of bowl games and more information:
http://www1.ncaa.org/eprise/main/membership/postseason_football/contacts
Competitions created by the Bowl Championship Series are not part of
the NCAA championship program, nor are they administered by an NCAA
committee or the national office staff.
In order for a NCAA Division I-A Football Championship to be
established, the NCAA Division I membership must consider such a
proposal through its normal legislative process. As of this date,
legislation to establish a Division I-A championship has not been
considered by the membership.
Through the years there have been several efforts to address the
subject. In 1976, a proposal to establish a Division I-A football
championship was introduced on the recommendation of a special
committee that had studied the feasibility of a playoff. This proposal,
however, was withdrawn and there was no discussion on the Convention
floor. A resolution was presented during the 1988 Convention that
stated the Division I-A membership did not support the creation of a
national championship in the sport of football, which passed by a vote
of 98 in favor, 13 opposed and one abstention. In 1994, a panel was
formed to gather information regarding the viability of establishing a
Division I-A football championship. The panel forwarded a report to the
NCAA Presidents Commission; however, it was decided that the
Association would not pursue a Division I-A championship at that time.
For more information, listen to a recent podcast of “Mondays with
Myles,” as NCAA President Myles Brand discusses postseason football
with NCAA blogger Josh Centor:
http://www.doubleazone.com/2006/12/mondays_with_myles_whats_the_d.html
Also see the following entry on the Double-A Zone:
http://www.doubleazone.com/2006/12/answering_your_questions_about.html
2. How is the NCAA involved in the bowl games?
The
Postseason Football Licensing Subcommittee of the NCAA Division I
Championships/Competition Cabinet includes one representative from each
Division I-A conference. The subcommittee is responsible for issues
involving postseason football contests. There are currently 32 bowls
licensed by the NCAA.
Postseason
bowls have long been a tradition and a reward for a successful football
season. Bowls are an extra contest beyond the limits established in
Bylaw 17.11.5.2, and are played after the end of the regular season as
defined in Bylaw 18.7.1. Bowls for student-athletes involve additional
practice time, physical dedication, risk of injury and, consequently,
require NCAA authorization and regulation to protect student-athlete
safety and well-being. Bowls ordinarily benefit sponsoring communities,
participating member institutions and student-athletes, and must be
regulated to preserve these benefits.
Because
bowls are licensed by the NCAA and benefit from enabling NCAA bylaws,
the public identifies bowls as a part of NCAA football. Bowls are a
limited joint venture with the organizing committee, participating
conferences, NCAA member institutions and the NCAA. If a bowl were to
fail its purposes, its community, its participating institutions or
participating student-athletes, the NCAA would be expected to prevent
and remedy the situation. The goodwill and intellectual property of the
NCAA is therefore affected by the success and failure of the bowls.
Here is a link to the 2006 Postseason Football Handbook:
http://www.ncaa.org/library/handbooks/football/2006/2006_postseason_football_handbook.pdf
3. How is officiating handled for bowl games?
Officials
for postseason football games licensed each year by the NCAA are
assigned under the jurisdiction of the NCAA Postseason Football
Licensing Subcommittee. The national coordinator along with three
Division I-A supervisors of officials work with the subcommittee to
coordinate crew assignments and make any changes to ensure neutral
crews are assigned to games after the teams have been invited to
participate. The NCAA staff liaison to the subcommittee also
participates in this process along with the national supervisor of
officials, who is a permanent ex officio member of the officials
subcommittee.
For a detailed list of guidelines for officials, see pages 28-30 of the 2006 Postseason Football Handbook:
http://www.ncaa.org/library/handbooks/football/2006/2006_postseason_football_handbook.pdf
4. What are the new NCAA football classification terms?
The
Division I-A, I-AA and I-AAA designations were confusing and as a
result, misapplied by the public, boosters and media when referring not
only to their local football programs but also to other sports such as
basketball. Additionally, due to the greater awareness of specific
conferences and schools, the I-A label was rarely emphasized by the I-A
membership, which only caused greater confusion about the I-AA
classification.
The Division I Board of Directors, comprised of Division I presidents and chancellors voted on the change in August 2006.
The
Football Bowl Subdivision (formerly I-A) includes those programs that
compete in an effort to participate in the postseason bowl system (the
32 NCAA-licensed events which includes the Bowl Championship Series).
The
NCAA Football Championship Subdivision includes those programs that
compete in an effort to participate in the NCAA championship postseason
structure (one of the 88 NCAA national championships).
Use
of the new terms officially commences December 15 at the 2006 Division
I Football Championship in Chattanooga, Tennessee. However the new
terms are being used throughout all preliminary rounds of the
championship and on promotional/informational materials distributed
prior to the championship.
Here is a quick guide:
Previous Name |
New Name |
|
|
Division I-A |
Football Bowl Subdivision |
I-A (short hand) |
Bowl Subdivision |
I-A (acronym for NCAA manual use) |
FBS |
Bowl Championship Series |
Same |
|
|
Division I-AA |
NCAA Football Championship Subdivision |
I-AA (short hand) |
Football Championship Subdivision |
I-AA (acronym for NCAA manual use) |
FCS |
NCAA Division I-AA Football Championship |
NCAA Division I Football Championship |
Division I-AA Football Committee |
Division I Football Championship Committee |
|
|
Division I-AAA |
Division I |
|
|
Division I (all other sports) |
Same |
5. What is the payout structure for the BCS games?
The NCAA compiles the finances for the bowl games as part of its licensing role for the contests.
Here is a link to 2005-06 NCAA postseason football finances:
http://www1.ncaa.org/membership/postseason_football/finances
Link to USA Today article on bowl payouts:
http://www.usatoday.com/sports/college/football/2006-12-06-bowl-payouts_x.htm
6. Who are the media contacts for the BCS?
Charles Bloom, associate commissioner for media relations, Southeastern Conference, 205-458-3000, cbloom@sec.org.
Bill Hancock, administrator, Bowl Championship Series, (913) 341-8151, bcs-hancock@kc.rr.com.
Here is a link to individual bowl contact information, schedules and what teams are playing in each bowl:
http://www1.ncaa.org/eprise/main/membership/postseason_football/contacts
7. Separate from the bowl games, how are football championships structured in Divisions I, II and III?
NCAA Football Championship Subdivision (formerly Division I-AA)
The
Division I Football Championship provides for a maximum field of 16
teams. Teams play first-round games on the campuses of competing teams.
Eight member conferences have been granted automatic qualification for
the 2006 championship. The remaining eight teams will be selected at
large by the Division I-AA football committee.
The
top four teams in the 16-team bracket for the championship will be
seeded. Team pairings will be determined by geographical proximity,
with the exception that teams from the same conference may not be
paired in the first round.
At-large
teams shall be selected by the Division I-AA football committee,
assisted by four regional advisory committees that serve in an advisory
capacity only.
Additional Football Criteria. Conferences
must conduct regular-season, round-robin play among the members to
determine the champion. The Division I-AA football committee may grant
exceptions to the round-robin requirement subject to approval of the
NCAA Executive Committee.
Certification of Eligibility/Availability
[Reference:
Certification of Eligibility/Availability in the Division I General
Section and Bylaws 3.2.4, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16 and 31.2.1.7 in the NCAA
Manual.]
Only
student-athletes eligible under Bylaws 12, 13, 14, 15 and 16 may
compete in NCAA championships. In accordance with Bylaw 3.2.4, member
institutions are required to certify the eligibility of their
student-athletes before the beginning of each academic year and to
withhold ineligible student-athletes from all intercollegiate
competition. Member institutions are reminded to notify the NCAA
national office before the selection date for each championship of any
student-athlete who may have participated in regular-season competition
but subsequently is determined to be ineligible or unavailable for NCAA
championship competition.
For the Division I Football Championship, the championship liaison must be notified before November 3.
Division II Football Championship
The
top-seeded team, as determined by the governing sports committee, shall
be provided the opportunity to host first-round, second-round,
quarterfinal and semifinal competition, provided the specific criteria
that have been developed by the governing sports committee have been
met, as well as the following general site-selection criteria:
1. Quality and availability of the facility and other necessary accommodations;
2.
Revenue potential (e.g., a financial guarantee or guideline that
ensures fiscal responsibility and is appropriate for the particular
event, as recommended by the governing sports committee and approved by
the Championships Committee); and
3. Attendance history and potential.
For
the championship, prospective hosts for first-round, second-round,
quarterfinal and semifinal games are required to submit proposed
budgets with 75 percent guaranteed net receipts of $10,000, $10,000,
$15,000 and $20,000, respectively; once these minimums have been
guaranteed, the Division II Football Committee then will award playoff
sites based on the stated criteria above. Please note that teams from
the same conference will be paired in the first round if seeding
justifies such a pairing.
Division III Football Championship
The
Division III Championships Committee has prioritized the site-selection
criteria in the following order for Division III championships:
1. Quality and availability of the facility and other necessary accommodations;
2.
Geographical location (including such factors as rotation of sites,
weather conditions, accessibility and transportation costs);
3. Seeding; and
4. Attendance history and revenue potential, which shall be considered necessary to assure fiscal responsibility.
The Division III Football Committee will award sites for the championship in the following manner:
First- and second-round, quarterfinal and semifinal contests—Sites
will be awarded to the highest-seeded teams in each of the brackets
(assuming that these teams have met all of the site-selection criteria
and have submitted bids to host).
For more information, football championship handbooks in all three divisions can be found at this link:
www2.ncaa.org/portal/media_and_events/ncaa_publications/championship_handbooks/fall/football/mens/index.html
8. What are NCAA rules regarding bowl gifts?
NCAA
members feel it is important to allow mementos or other awards to honor
the hard work of student-athletes to achieve athletics success, from
regular-season participation through a national championship. To not
allow this would mean national champions could not receive a ring,
Heisman winners could not receive a trophy, or seniors could not
receive a keepsake honoring years of hard work. Allowing these awards
with reasonable limits is well within the confines of amateurism.
The
limits are meant to level the playing field. NCAA members don’t want a
large, profitable program or event to be able to provide more valuable
gifts than less-profitable schools or events. The limits allow a
reasonable award while helping to ensure that everybody participates on
an equal footing.
For detailed information, see Bylaw 16.1.4 and Figures 16-1, 16-2 and 16-3 in the Division I manual.
9. Is it unfair that athletes not in the post-season don’t receive an additional award?
There
are allowances for awards in regular season participation. The limits
for annual participation are: Awards valued up to $175/sport for
underclassmen and awards valued at up to $325/sport for seniors.
10. Can athletes receive cash?
Awards
may not include cash, gift certificates, a cash-equivalent award
(something that can be traded for cash, trade services or merchandise),
country club or other sports club membership.
11. What are the limits?
PARTICIPATION –
**
Annual Participation: Institution may give awards valued at up to
$175/sport (underclassmen); and awards valued at up to $325/sport
(seniors).
** Postseason conference championship or
tournament: Institution and event managers may give a COMBINED total of
awards valued at up to $325.
** Postseason NCAA
championship or tournament: Institution may give awards valued at up to
$325; there is no limit for what the NCAA may give.
**
All-star game or bowl: Institution may give awards valued at up to
$350. Event Management may give awards valued at up to $500.
Note: Prior to 2005, the maximum amount for event management was
$350. Effective 8/1/05, the maximum amount for event management was
changed to $500 to make bowl game awards more consistent with the
awards received by student-athletes who participate in NCAA
championship events. The increase provides a direct benefit to
student-athletes at no additional cost to institutions.
**
Other established meets, tournaments: Institution and event management
may give a COMBINED total of awards valued at up to $350.
CHAMPIONSHIP –
**
NCAA National Championship: Institution and conference may each give
awards valued at up to $415 per each championship conducted by the NCAA.
** Non-NCAA National Championship: same as above.
**
Regular season conference champs: Institution and conference may each
give awards valued at up to $325. (NOTE: If same team wins regular
season and tournament, the combined total shall not exceed awards
valued at up to $325).
** Postseason conference champs:
Institution and conference may each give awards valued at up to $325.
(NOTE: If same team wins regular season and tournament, the combined
total shall not exceed awards valued at up to $325).
12. How are the limits determined?
The
award totals were revised in 2004-05 to adjust for inflation. The last
time awards were modified was in the mid-1990s. Due to inflation, it is
becoming increasingly difficult to purchase the same or similar types
of awards from year to year. The increase allowed institutions to
purchase the same or similar awards for its student-athletes and still
be within the specified NCAA limitations.
13. Why is there no limit for what the NCAA may give for participation in an NCAA tournament?
Participating
in the NCAA championship is the ultimate achievement athletically in
college. So, the membership is not concerned with putting limits on
participation awards for NCAA events. The NCAA does not have a
competitor, as institutions do, that would claim a recruiting advantage
because of the amount its awards are worth.
14. Is merchandise other than trophies, rings, etc. allowed, including electronics?
Merchandise is allowed, but it must abide by the limits stated above and may not be re-sold.
15. May any awards be sold or traded?
Awards
received for intercollegiate athletics participation may not be sold,
exchanged or assigned for another item of value, even if the
student-athlete's name or picture does not appear on the award.
16. For additional information, please see the below link to 2006 NCAA College Football Information Resources:
http://www2.ncaa.org/portal/media_and_events/press_room/2006/august/20060816_football_call.html
-30-