| Date | Location | Result | |
| Dec 12, 2009 | Florence, Alabama | Northwest Mo. St. 30, Grand Valley St. 23 | Box score |
| Dec 05, 2009 | Maryville, Mo. | Northwest Mo. St. 56, California (Pa.) 31 | Box score |
| Dec 05, 2009 | Allendale, Mich. | Grand Valley St. 41, Carson-Newman 27 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | Florence, Ala. | Carson-Newman 24, North Alabama 21 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | Duluth, Minn. | Grand Valley St. 24, Minn. Duluth 10 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | West Liberty, WV | California (Pa.) 57, West Liberty 35 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | Ellensburg, WA | Northwest Mo. St. 21, Central Wash. 20 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | West Liberty, WV | West Liberty 84, Edinboro 63 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Allendale, Mich. | Grand Valley St. 44, Hillsdale 27 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Duluth, Minn. | Minn. Duluth 42, Neb.-Kearney 7 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Maryville, Mo. | Northwest Mo. St. 35, Abilene Christian 10 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Shippensburg, PA | California (Pa.) 26, Shippensburg 21 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Jeff. City, Tenn. | Carson-Newman 59, West Ala. 41 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Florence, Ala. | North Alabama 41, Arkansas Tech 28 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Ellensburg, WA | Central Wash. 27, Tarleton St. 6 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Albany, GA | West Ala. 24, Albany St. (GA) 22 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Kingsville, TX | Tarleton St. 57, Texas A&M-Kingsville 56 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | East Stroudsburg PA | Edinboro 31, East Stroudsburg 16 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Kearney, NE | Neb.-Kearney 35, Saginaw Valley 20 | Box score |
| 11/14/09 | California, Pa. | California (Pa.) 42, Fayetteville St. 13 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Russellville, AR | Arkansas Tech 41, UNC Pembroke 13 | Box score |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Wichita Falls, TX | Abilene Christian 24, Midwestern St. 21 | Box score |
| Nov. 14 2009 | Mankato, Minn. | Hillsdale 27, Minn. St. Mankato 24 | Box score |