| Date | Location | Result | |
| Dec 19, 2009 | Salem, Va. | Wis.-Whitewater 38, Mount Union 28 | Box score |
| Dec 12, 2009 | Whitewater, WI | Wis.-Whitewater 27, Linfield 17 | Box score |
| Dec 12, 2009 | Alliance, OH | Mount Union 24, Wesley 7 | Box score |
| Dec 5, 2009 | Whitewater, WI | Wis.-Whitewater 31, Wittenberg 13 | Box score |
| 12/5/09 | McMinnville, Ore. | Linfield 31, St. Thomas (MN) 20 | Box score |
| Dec 05, 2009 | Dover, Del. | Wesley 12, Johns Hopkins 0 | Box score |
| Dec 05, 2009 | Alliance, OH | Mount Union 55, Albright 3 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | UST/St. Paul | St. Thomas (MN) 34, Coe 7 | Box score |
| 11/28/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Johns Hopkins 31, Thomas More 29 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | Dover, Del. | Wesley 43, Mississippi Col. 9 | Box score |
| 11/28/09 | McMinnville, Ore. | Linfield 53, Mary Hardin-Baylor 21 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | Springfield, Ohio | Wittenberg 34, Trine 17 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | Doylestown, PA | Albright 27, Delaware Valley 3 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | Alliance, OH | Mount Union 62, Montclair St. 14 | Box score |
| Nov 28, 2009 | Whitewater, WI | Wis.-Whitewater 45, Illinois Wesleyan 7 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Cleveland, OH | TRINE 51, Case Western Reserve 38 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Springfield, Ohio | Wittenberg Univ. 42, Mount St. Joseph 14 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Monmouth, Ill. | Univ. of St. Thomas 43, Monmouth College 21 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Whitewater, WI | UW-Whitewater 70, Lakeland College 7 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Dover, Del. | Wesley 55, N.C. Wesleyan 23 | Box score |
| 11/21/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. | Thomas More 49, DePauw 39 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Doylestown, PA | Delaware Valley Coll 66, Susquehanna Univ. 7 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Alliance, OH | Mount Union 55, Washington&Jefferson 0 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Bloomington, Ill. | Illinois Wesleyan 41, Wabash 35 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Hampden-Sydney, VA | Johns Hopkins 23, Hampden-Sydney 7 | Box score |
| 11/21/09 | Montgomery, AL | Mississippi College 56, Huntingdon College 35 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Alfred, NY | Albright 35, Alfred University 25 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Pella, Iowa | Mary Hardin-Baylor 42, Central College 40 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Montclair, NJ | Montclair State 38, Maine Maritime 22 | Box score |
| 11/21/09 | McMinnville, Ore. | Linfield 38, Cal Lutheran 17 | Box score |
| Nov 21, 2009 | Collegeville, Minn. | Coe 34, St. John's (MN) 27 | Box score |